And why I don’t like it.
Diet: Both ‘the kinds of food a person, animal or community habitually eats’ and ‘a special course of food which a person restricts themselves, either to lose weight or for medical reasons’
Calorie: ‘A unit of energy’
Deficit: ‘The amount by which something … is too small’
Nourishment: ‘The food necessary for growth, health and good condition’
(Google Dictionary)
Anyone who knows my style knows I’m not into counting calories or macros or anything to do with the #iifym life. I have successfully lost weight and kept it off by focusing on eating whole, nutritious foods and monitoring my portion sizes. It’s still my firm belief that this is the gateway to a forever happy, healthy lifestyle and my preferred approach to diet and lifestyle.
However, that’s not to say that counting calories does not have it’s place. It does and in my opinion, that place is education. It teaches you the value of food. Look at it like this, you go grocery shopping and the bill blows out to $100 over your budget and you have no idea how or why. To work it out, you take a look at the receipt to see which items are costing you the most money. The same goes for your food, if you’re struggling to lose weight or putting it on and you don’t know why, you need to take a closer look at what’s taking up your calorie budget.
I’ve hit a plateau with my training and weight loss results and so, I wanted to take a closer look at my diet and review where I can make some changes. I decided to count my calories for a week, I calculated this to be 1631 calories per day using the Harris-Benedict formula/ calculation for determining an estimate. I put my goal at fat loss, and exercise at ‘light’ (I haven’t been training much lately – more on that to come) to reach this number for my height and weight. Here is what happened and my pros and cons list:
Pros:
– Counting my calories did enable me to understand the value of food I am eating better. This was most apparent with some whole foods like coconut milk, nuts and grains that can be really high in calories. Whilst good for us, when wanting or needing to adhere to a calorie budget, these foods can easily blow that out.
– Eating under 1631 calories a day for me was a REAL challenge for me. I sit far more comfortably at around 1800-2000 calories. To maintain my figure or be in a slight deficit to lose weight at that calorie range, I NEED to be doing a combination of strength training and walking at a minimum. A HIIT session 1-2 times per week wouldn’t go astray either. Of course I could eat less, but I refuse. I’ll share why further on.
– Calculating my weekly calories (1631 x 7 = 11417) worked better because it would enable me to flex up on the weekend and down during the week. However, what it actually made me realise is that I’m doing far more damage on the weekends than I realised. A couple of vinos here, extra treats there and perhaps a pizza has meant the winter layer I’m now looking to remove is due to my weekends alone, I don’t have the balance right, but I can fix that.
Cons:
– People don’t eat calories they eat ‘food’ and ‘meals’ so tracking accurately is difficult and time consuming. At best it’s an estimate but any decent Health Coach or Personal Trainer will tell you that.
– I didn’t look forward to any meals because I was caught up in how much the food was going to ‘cost me’, rather than thinking about what the foods would do for my body and enjoying them.
– The more I thought about calories, the less I thought about nutrients. I did not enjoy looking for ways to constantly strip down my food, making it ‘lighter’ which ultimately meant restricting and depriving my body of nutrients.
– I drank more coffee to try and ‘fill up’ on less calories, rather than eating for example a banana full of other good things.
Summary:
I still think calorie counting is a great tool to educate people about the quantity of the food they’re eating. However, you shouldn’t live in a calorie restriction or be ‘on a diet’ forever. Learn what you need to learn and work on turning those lessons into habits for your every day life. My ONLY food rule is ‘strive for nourishment but not for perfection’. This enables me to constantly look for ways I can add more nourishing foods into my day and enjoy food, minus the guilt. When I want to lose some weight, I stick to whole foods for my snacks, monitor my portion sizes using the thumb, palm, fist method and ensure I’m drinking plenty of water.
Calorie counting helps some feel in control, accountable and on track for their health goals. It makes others feel overly restricted and bad about food. It’s not to say one method is better than another, it’s just about trying different things until you get the recipe right for you. Speaking of which, see below for my best creation yet! Your reward for being a beautiful soul and reading my blog. I appreciate that so much!

NO BAKE CHEWY PROTEIN SLICE – makes 16 at approx 214cal per slice (17gC, 13.8gF, 5.8gP)
- 2 cups rolled oats
- 1/2 cup desiccated coconut
- 2 scoops whey protein (I used Salted Caramel Happy Whey)
- 1/2 cup goji berries (can use any ‘filler you like’ i.e. almonds, peanuts, cranberries etc.)
- 1/2 cup dark choc chips (optional)
- 1/4 cup coconut oil
- 1/2 cup rice malt syrup (or preferred sticky sweetener)
- 3 tbsp tahini (or nut butter of choice)

*Combine dry and wet ingredients together in a bowl.
*Press mixture firmly into a lined baking tray (important so it sticks and doesn’t fall apart like granola)
*Place in freezer for 1 hour to set.
*Heat a sharp knife under hot water to cut into 16 slices.
*Store in an airtight container in the fridge and try not to eat all at once!

















